North Rhine-Westphalia Green Economy Report 2024

Client

Ministry of the Environment, Nature and Transport for North Rhine-Westphalia

Year

2024

Partner

Institute for Ecological Economic Research


The North Rhine-Westphalian green economy has been experiencing a boost in growth since 2020. Between 2020 and 2023, the annual gross value added in the sector rose by 9.2 billion euros to almost 52.8 billion euros in total. The number of people in employment increased by 21,600 over the same period and now stands at around 599,000 people.

The North Rhine-Westphalia Green Economy Report will be published for the fifth time this year. On behalf of the State Environment Ministry, the economic and ecological importance of the green economy, its development and technological priorities as well as its international positioning were identified.

Driving force with ecological impact

In North Rhine-Westphalia, the environmental industry not only makes an economic contribution to society, but also a significant ecological contribution. The Green Economy Report estimates the performance of the green economy in North Rhine-Westphalia in 2023 as follows:

  • Economic value added: 52.8 billion euros
  • Ecological value added (for example, the recovery of important resources through recycling or the preservation of natural landscapes and biodiversity): 9.3 billion euros
  • Avoidance of environmental damage (avoided greenhouse gas and pollutant emissions): 19.6 billion euros

The overall ecological performance of the green economy is based on the combined avoided environmental costs and the ecological added value, which amounted to 28.9 billion euros in 2023.

The economic balance sheet is shaped by the large sub-markets

  • "Materials, Material Efficiency and Resource Management" (2023: 16.9 billion euros gross value added, employing 192,000 people),
  • "Environmentally friendly mobility" (2023: 8.6 billion euros gross value added, employing 130,000 people) and
  • "Energy Efficiency and Energy Savings" (2023: 8.2 billion euros gross value added, employing 92,000 people).

With 599,000 people in total, the green economy in 2023 comprised more employees than the metal industry and mechanical engineering in North Rhine-Westphalia combined.

Actors from North Rhine-Westphalia are engaged in some of the most important innovation topics for transformation. The report highlights outstanding innovation projects in the areas of the circular economy and water management, but also in mitigation and protection technologies. The focus of innovation is on the recycling of batteries and wind and photovoltaic systems.

Reporting and monitoring system

North Rhine-Westphalia was the first federal state to adopt its own interdisciplinary environmental strategy, which it has been pursuing since 2010. With the Green Economy Report, the State has established a reporting and monitoring system that can be used to assess the economic importance of the green economy.
The Green Economy Report also serves as a starting point for environmental and economic policy measures, as well as a benchmark for measuring exactly how successful they are.

Our approach

The official classification by economic activity and product group does not include the green economy within its classification. So, in order to assess its economic significance empirically, a statistical delimitation of economic activities and products was therefore necessary. Our criteria stipulated that the activities and products had to have a direct environmental benefit, an effect as an environmentally friendly substitute or a supporting value-added or climate adaptation function. If a product, process or service meets one of these criteria, it is considered part of the green economy.

We used our envigos model for the analysis. The parameters were distinguished in terms of sub-markets, market segments and the specific technology areas of the environmental sector. We also examined the regional characteristics of this cross-sectional industry in the nine economic regions of North Rhine-Westphalia.

To give an indication of the innovation performance of the green economy, the patent applications of companies based in North Rhine-Westphalian were analysed.

Links and downloads

To the Green Economy Report 2024 (website in German, State Government of NRW)

Impetus for the Green Economy 2023 (in German)

Green Economy Report 2022 (in German)

Further information on the Green Economy Report (in German)

Project team: Tim Bichlmeier, Philipp Hutzenthaler, Jannis Lambert, Oliver Lühr, Robert Norpoth, Michelle Reuter, Katharina Wilkskamp, Vera Wechner

Latest update: 07.11.2024

Do you have questions?

Your contact at Prognos

Jannis Lambert

Principal

View profile

Oliver Lühr

Partner, Head of Environmental, Circular Economy & Climate Change

View profile

More studies & projects on this topic

Successful implementation of the Talent Booster Mechanism: Completion of Pillar 1

2025
| Project update

The Talent Booster Mechanism supports eleven EU regions that are suffering from a decline in the working-age population and a low proportion of university graduates. The first pillar has been successfully implemented.

Impact of demographic transition on regional labour markets

ongoing
| Project

A shrinking workforce, digitalisation and decarbonisation: Prognos examined the specific effects of global trends on regional labour markets.

OVERLAP: Project results

2025
| Project conclusion

The results of the OVERLAP project show that demographic changes, digital transformation and the need for a green transition are simultaneously affecting regions across the EU.

Competitiveness of European clean energy technologies

2025
| Project

In recent years, Europe has maintained its strong position in the global market for clean energy technologies, but faces growing competition. On behalf of the European Commission, we examined the competitiveness of these technologies.

Full-day care for primary school children: where the federal states currently stand

ongoing
| Project

Germany needs around 166,000 additional full-time places for primary school children by the summer. We are examining how this can be achieved for the Federal Ministry of Education.

Guest article in Handelsblatt: “What drives a trade association into the arms of the AfD?”

2025
| Expertise

The party offers no constructive solutions to any of the current economic challenges. The fact that the Verband der Familienunternehmen is nevertheless opening up to it is dangerous, says Christian Böllhoff in his guest article in Handelsblatt.

Evaluation of the European Green Deal

2025
| Project

How effective are EU cohesion and structural policies in driving green change in Europe? We examined this and other questions together with COWI, Milieu and CSIL on behalf of the European Commission (DG REGIO).

S3 Community of Practice: Smart Specialisation in Europe

ongoing
| Project

How can smart specialisation be empirically justified and managed? On behalf of the European Commission (DG REGIO), Prognos is implementing the S3 Community of Practice (S3 CoP) together with a network of partners.

Regional contributions to climate neutrality

ongoing
| Project

For the European Observation Network for Territorial Development and Cohesion (ESPON), we are investigating how regions can work together more effectively to protect the climate.

Mid-term evaluation of the Single Market Programme (SMP)

2025
| Project

The Single Market Programme promotes the EU internal market in order to strengthen it, standardise it and make it more competitive. Prognos was involved in the mid-term evaluation of the programme.

About us

We combine economic research and strategy consulting for sustainable decisions in politics, business and society. Our robust data, precise analyses and scientifically based findings enable fact-based progress – financially independent, politically neutral. 

Learn more