German Steel Federation
2022
The steel industry is a commodity industry situated at the beginning of value chains. Their products are used as inputs in many other sectors, for example in the automotive, mechanical engineering or construction industries. Using the blast furnace converter route, which is the technology traditionally used until now, the production of primary steel results in considerable carbon dioxide emissions.
Both Germany and the EU seek to gradually reduce greenhouse gas emissions (GHG emissions) in all areas of the economy. Germany should achieve zero net GHG emissions from 2045, and by 2050 this should be the case for the whole EU. Germany’s steel industry is thus faced with the task of achieving GHG neutrality in the coming decades. For this purpose, it will be necessary to switch the production of primary steel to the so-called direct hydrogen reduction process. The study for the German Steel Federation calculates how this transformation can be accomplished in two scenarios.
With the help of scenario calculations, we examine the climate-political framework conditions under which the transformation of the steel industry in Germany can succeed. By successful transformation we mean that by the end of the transition phase the production of primary steel should be completely GHG-neutral, with no loss to production volumes or employment because of the transformation. The two scenarios were created using the agent-based LABS simulation model:
In order to achieve Germany’s and the EU's climate goals, the steel industry plans to switch the primary steel route to low-GHG and in the future GHG-free hydrogen-based production processes. The simulation calculations show that if companies are not assisted, the decarbonisation of the steel industry in Europe and Germany is not feasible as the production costs of the low-emission production processes in the primary steel route are currently and in the mid-term significantly higher than those of conventional processes.
Even in a scenario where the CBAM provides (emission) cost parity on the basis of conventional production between domestic and foreign countries, around 20 percent of domestic production would be eliminated – even with government subsidies. In addition to the temporary continuation of free emission allowances, a government grant of 50 percent for capital expenditure would be almost sufficient for the complete changeover to the hydrogen direct reduction method. In the case of ongoing operation costs, a subsidy of 100 percent is required if the companies concerned are to remain permanently on the market.
The study and further information can be found on the German Steel Federation website:
Study "Transformation Paths for the Steel Industry in Germany" (PDF, in German)
Results at a glance (PDF, in German)
WV Stahl press release (PDF, in German)
Jan Limbers, Dr Michael Böhmer
Senior Expert
Chief Economist, Head of Corporate Services
The automotive industry continues to undergo fundamental change worldwide. How does this transformation affect the Saarland economy?
What are the biggest sales opportunities? How can the location gain visibility worldwide? Further development of the strategic foundations.
A study for the vbw on the impact of the gas price brake for Bavarian companies.
We investigate the climate-damaging emissions, water consumption and energy consumption of the German pharmaceutical industry on behalf of the Association of Research-Based Pharmaceu-tical Companies (Verband Forschender Arzneimittel-Hersteller e. V.).
Increasing geopolitical tensions are endangering the world trading system. On behalf of the vbw, Prognos investigated possible consequences for the economy in Germany and the EU.
DG Regio's new platform aims to help EU regions develop strategies to attract talent. Prognos is, among other things, leading the knowledge generation.
The liberalisation of the electricity markets in the EU was once supposed to reduce costs. Sven Kreidelmeyer writes in the Swiss magazine "Die Volkswirtschaft" about the effects of free competition and current developments in the European electricity sector, among other things.
Why it’s time for Germany to take an honest look at itself. A guest commentary in the WirtschaftsWoche by Dr Michael Böhmer.
The aim of Germany Trade and Invest (GTAI) is to promote German foreign trade. Prognos investigated whether they are using their budget effectively.
Retiring at 63 is very popular. In 2021 alone, more than 270,000 people took the option of early retirement. These were the findings of our study for the INSM.
Prognos is one of the oldest economic research centres in Europe. Founded at the University of Basel, Prognos experts have been conducting research for a wide range of clients from the public and private sectors since 1959 – politically independent, scientifically sound.