Back to the project overview

digital transformation

Digital hubs promote start-ups in North Rhine-Westphalia


Ministry of Economic Affairs, Innovation, Digitalisation and Energy of the State of North Rhine-Westphalia (MWIDE)



As part of the Digital Economy NRW (DWNRW) initiative, in 2016, five digital hubs were established to bring together digital start-ups, established companies, science, and investors. This networking of the various groups of actors is supported by the state of North Rhine-Westphalia. Prognos evaluated the impact of the five DWNRW hubs in the first funding period and parts of the second funding period, and from this drew recommendations on how funding might be allocated in the future. The results of the evaluation have now been published.

What the digital hubs in NRW have achieved

The five DWNRW hubs have now developed into regional platforms for the digital economy in the Rhineland (Aachen, Bonn, Düsseldorf), Münsterland (Münster) and the Ruhr region (Essen). So far, about 1,000 start-ups have become part of the hub network and more than 55,000 people have already participated in hub events. Around four out of five users surveyed say they have benefited from the hubs in the areas of network & visibility as well as knowledge & competence. In addition, the hubs’ users often recommended them to others. According to the respondents, the hubs motivate entrepreneurship, contribute to networking and the development of start-ups, and support in promotion and financing. The DWNRW hubs’ users also considered the prices to be appropriate. Only two areas are considered to have had no great impact: access to customers and companies, and access to capital and investors.

How digital hubs can be developed further

Prognos recommends continuing promotion of the DWNRW hubs and developing them in some areas. The hubs should, for example, have international networks and establish partner ships with hub-like organisations in other countries. In addition, access to capital for start-ups should be strengthened, for example, through the establishment of business angel networks and their own seed funds. In addition, the hub acceleration programmes need to be further developed and expanded. Thematically focusing on the hubs could further raise their profile and contribute to the division of labour in the start-up ecosystem.

Our approach

For the evaluation, the DWNRW hubs’ system of indicators was analysed. In addition, secondary statistical data was evaluated, and 45 interviews conducted. The focus was on an online survey of around 480 participants. In addition, the empirical results were presented in round-table discussions with the DWNRW hubs, and the implications for action were discussed.

Directly to the evaluation (; in German)

Further informationen on the initiative (; in German)

Do you have questions?

Your contact at Prognos

Dr Jan-Philipp Kramer

Vice-Director, Head of EU-Services

View profile

Moritz Glettenberg


View profile

Our work on this topic

Take a look at our latest projects and activities.

Cluster meets Regions workshop: Baltic region clusters

| Event

The European Cluster Collaboration Platform is organising the second "Cluster meets Regions" workshop with a focus on Lithuania and the Baltic Sea Region.

Further development of the European Cluster Collaboration Platform

| Project

The aim of the European Cluster Collaboration Platform (ECCP) is to strengthen the European economy through cooperation. Together with our partners, we are developing the ECCP into a single point of contact for cluster organisations in Europe.

Saarland StrategyPlus 2021-2023

| Project

On behalf of the Saarland State Chancellery, we have assisted with the update of the Saarland innovation strategy and have prepared the strategy paper, “StrategyPlus 2021–2023".

European Regional Development Fund: Evaluation of RTD-Investments

| Project

Evaluation of investments in Research & Technological Development infrastructures and activities supported by the ERDF from 2007 to 2013.

Results of the Big Data analysis for the development of territorial indicators


Together with DevStat, we analyzed for ESPON which digital platforms are suitable for deriving territorial indicators based on Big Data and how these can be used.

Cluster Initiatives Follow-up

| Project

For the European Commission, we evaluated the impact of the EU cluster initiatives

How effective are EU support programs for innovation in SMEs?

| Project

The EU offers a wide range of innovation support for SMEs. Together with partners, Prognos investigated the extent to which the EU funding programs achieve their goals.

Evaluation of the cluster initiatives

| Project

For the EU Commission, we evaluate the EU cluster programmes together with CSES and IDEA Consulting Group.

Fields of action for lignite regions

| Project

How can structural change in lignite mining areas succeed? A Prognos study commissioned by the Federal Ministry of Economics reveals possible approaches and instruments.

About us

Prognos – Providing Orientation.

Prognos is one of the oldest economic research centres in Europe. Founded at the University of Basel, Prognos experts have been conducting research for a wide range of clients from the public and private sectors since 1959 – politically independent, scientifically sound.

Learn more