Reforming
environmentally
harmful subsidies

 

Client

Bertelsmann Stiftung

Year

2023

Partner

Forum Ökologisch-Soziale Marktwirtschaft


How harmful to the climate are state subsidies in the transport and industry sectors? And can reforms protect the climate by saving money and redistributing it more effectively?

These questions are taken from the “Reforming climate-damaging subsidies” study conducted on behalf of the Bertelsmann Stiftung. The Forum Ökologisch-Soziale Marktwirtschaft (internationally known as Green Budget Germany), worked on propositions for reform while Prognos experts calculated their respective impacts.

Contradictory subsidies should be phased out

Subsidies such as the diesel rebate damage the climate. To achieve its climate goals Germany will have to reduce both direct and indirect subsidies that promote greenhouse gas emissions.

The study shows:

  • Even if Germany does not use the saved subsidy expenditure to finance decarbonisation, the negative economic effects are very small
  • Subsidising the use of fossil fuels while at the same time trying to avoid their use via other state-funded measures, is economically unwise

Reforms can have positive ecological and financial effects

The impact estimation and modelling for industry conducted by Prognos shows that reforms can have positive ecological and fiscal impacts, while only impacting cost effects on market shares, production, and employment, to a minor extent.

The modelling in the transport sector points to a substantial dismantling of subsidies. The reform of company car taxation or the diesel tax would lead to increased income tor the state, while at the same time reducing CO2.

It should be noted that our models are unable to illustrate all action/effect mechanisms and in terms of the company car reforms, in particular, we can assume far greater effects. On the one hand, faster electrification would lead to less emissions, equally, it also leads to less additional revenues due to the decreased taxation of electric company cars.

Overall, the distribution effects of the reforms are positively assessed.

Links and downloads

Study (PDF, in German)
More on the Bertelsmann Stiftung website (in German)

Project team: Andreas Brutsche, Alex Auf der Maur, Dr Andreas Kemmler, Dr Jan Limbers

Last update: 17.11.2023

Do you have questions?

Your contact at Prognos

Jan Limbers

Senior Expert

View profile

More studies & projects on this topic

Hydrogen prices for the industry

2025
| Project

Our study identifies the key cost components for low-carbon blue and green hydrogen and calculates the cost of supplying hydrogen to industry.

Energy prospects for Switzerland in 2060

ongoing
| Project

The Swiss Federal Office of Energy is planning to redesign its energy strategy for the period up to 2060. Under the leadership of Prognos, various scenarios are being developed for a secure and sustainable energy future for Switzerland. The focus is on the question of how rising electricity demand can be met in the future.

Efficiency of climate and energy subsidies in Austria

2025
| Project

The Republic of Austria promotes numerous energy efficiency measures. Prognos analysed these measures and drew up recommendations for further development.

Socially just transition to climate neutrality in the EU

ongoing
| Project

To facilitate the transition to a climate-neutral economy, Prognos is supporting the European Commission in implementing the European Fair Transition Observatory (EFTO).

Rail4Climate: Improving efficiency in the Austrian rail sector

ongoing
| Project

With Rail4Climate, the Climate and Energy Fund promotes capacity and efficiency improvements in the Austrian rail sector with a focus on digital operations control, data usage and automated maintenance. We support the project with an indicator-based evaluation system.

Carbon management study for the state of Brandenburg

2025
| Project

Prognos examined for the Ministry of Economic Affairs, Labor, Energy and Climate Protection of the State of Brandenburg what role CO2 capture, usage and storage could play in the state.

Sustainability management concept for municipal energy management

2025
| Project

Prognos and bridgingIT developed a concept for future internal sustainability management for a customer in the municipal energy sector.

International electricity price comparison

2025
| Project

Prognos compared international industrial electricity prices for the Austrian electricity industry. Based on this analysis, we also developed recommendations for government instruments to reduce electricity costs.

Design and implementation of the Resilience Expo

ongoing
| Project

Prognos is supporting the North Rhine-Westphalian Ministry of the Environment in organising, implementing and establishing the world's first trade exhibition for the climate adaptation industry.

Impact of extreme weather events on transport infrastructure

ongoing
| Project

Flooded streets, dried-up rivers, broken asphalt: we analyse the effects of extreme weather events on transport infrastructure and the economy.

About us

We combine economic research and strategy consulting for sustainable decisions in politics, business and society. Our robust data, precise analyses and scientifically based findings enable fact-based progress – financially independent, politically neutral. 

Learn more