Comparison of GHG
emissions from the use
of primary and recycled
raw materials for the
production of metals

Client

Recycling company

Year

2022


The use of recycled raw materials brings considerable benefits in terms of greenhouse gas emissions (GHG emissions) from products. For our client, a recycling company, it is important to present these benefits to its customers in a transparent and comprehensible manner and to communicate them to the public. This is done by comparing the GHG balance when using primary raw materials and recycled raw materials.

In addition to the investigation of aluminium and copper, particular attention was paid to the GHG balance of various steel production routes. The possibility of increased scrap input in the blast furnace and converter through the use of the recycled product was analysed as an additional steel production route.

How can the advantages of recycled raw materials be demonstrated transparently?

In order to inform industry, society and politics about the specific advantages of recycled raw materials, a well-founded basis for discussion regarding the advantages of recycled raw materials was created by means of product-specific GHG balancing (cradle-to-gate) along the entire value chain. Through a transparent calculation approach and assumptions, as well as a targeted focus on the main impact channels, the GHG saving potentials were made tangible and the benefits specifically emphasised.

The analysis framework was specifically tailored to the relevant requirements. For example, the GHG balance of the value chains of the three metals for primary and recycled raw materials included a module that analysed the explicit GHG footprint for all input and output material flows used for each production step. The GHG balance sheet also contained a transport module that showed the transport emissions along the entire value chain for the respective primary or recycled raw material.

How we analysed the results

In addition to a scientifically sound final documentation, a meaningful communication concept with "ten theses" on the selected products was developed in consultation with the client as a storyline for internal and external communication. Concrete partial results of the product-specific GHG balances as well as further case studies and facts, which make possible emission savings tangible, underpin the theses. Selected points were presented to the public at the IFAT trade fair.

Last update: 24.06.2024

Do you have questions?

Your contact at Prognos

Dr Jan Trenczek

Senior Project Manager, Head of Corporate Services

View profile

Nico Dietzsch

Consultant

View profile

More studies & projects on this topic

Analyses of Swiss energy use

ongoing
| Project

On behalf of the Swiss Federal Office of Energy (SFOE), we conduct an annual analysis of the development of energy consumption in Switzerland.

Ex-post analysis of Swiss energy consumption in 2024

2025
| Project update

The analysis for the Federal Office of Energy shows that final energy consumption has fallen significantly since 2000, mainly thanks to savings in space and process heating. At the same time, demand has risen in areas such as electrical appliances and building services. Consumption has not changed significantly since 2020.

CO₂ sinks – greenhouse gas neutrality in the EU and Germany

2026
| Project

How far have systems for storing and extracting CO2 developed in Europe? Our study for the German Environment Agency evaluated planned and ongoing CO2 capture projects in Europe, focusing on BECCUS and DACCUS projects.

Methane Emissions from Europe’s landfills

2026
| Project

Methane emissions from landfills are an often underestimated climate challenge. On commission by Kanadevia Inova, we investigated how these emissions develop over time and what levels they reach.

Energy efficiency analysis of electrical appliances

ongoing
| Project

On behalf of the Energy Agency for Electrical Appliances (eae), Prognos annually examines the development in the efficiency of electrical appliances and their influence on energy consumption in Switzerland.

Communicative support for the expansion of the distribution network in Schleswig-Holstein

ongoing
| Project

Prognos has been providing communications support for the network expansion of distribution network operator Schleswig-Holstein Netz since 2006.

Competitiveness of European clean energy technologies

2025
| Project

In recent years, Europe has maintained its strong position in the global market for clean energy technologies, but faces growing competition. On behalf of the European Commission, we examined the competitiveness of these technologies.

Evaluation of the European Green Deal

2025
| Project

How effective are EU cohesion and structural policies in driving green change in Europe? We examined this and other questions together with COWI, Milieu and CSIL on behalf of the European Commission (DG REGIO).

Green Tech: Digital technologies and sustainability

ongoing
| Project

The Federal Ministry of Economics promotes digital technologies that drive forward the economy’s green transformation. Together with partners, we are responsible for the accompanying research.

ADAC Mobility Index 2025

2025
| Project

Traffic jams and train delays increased significantly. But there were slight improvements in all other dimensions of the ADAC Mobility Index 2025.

About us

We combine economic research and strategy consulting for sustainable decisions in politics, business and society. Our robust data, precise analyses and scientifically based findings enable fact-based progress – financially independent, politically neutral. 

Learn more