German energy market design
vbw – Bavarian Industry Association
2024
The withdrawal from nuclear energy use and the envisaged withdrawal from coal energy by the end of 2030 means that new power generation plants will have to be built in the coming years. The plants in question concern above all renewable energies, but they will also include flexible gas power plants that can be used to bridge the gap when there is no available power from renewable sources. But how can the necessary investments in new power plants be refinanced? Which incentive instruments can policy set for these extensions without driving energy prices up further?
In a short study on behalf of the vbw – Bavarian Industry Association, we assessed the suitability of various political instruments.
It is not possible to finance the building of so-called residual power plants – that can assist if power from renewable sources is not sufficient – through energy sales alone. We compared the different incentive instruments for the building of these flexible gas power plants.
The “selective capacity mechanism” seems to be the most well suited to this and means that a power plant is refinanced in the way that is most cost effective for energy customers: The power plants receive payment for the provision of their capacity, in addition to their earnings for delivering electricity to the energy market.
So that the additionally built gas power plants can be operated in a way that is greenhouse gas neutral in the long term, they must also have the technical capacity to use hydrogen. However, the implementation of additional instruments will be required to avoid the rises in electricity prices that would otherwise result from the higher costs of converting hydrogen to electricity.
Renewable energies should continue to be subsidised.
In the EU, discussions are under way about Contracts for Difference, which could be used to refinance the subsidies for renewables. The Contracts for Difference guarantee renewable energy plants a minimum price for their supplied energy. The difference between the minimum price and the market price is taken care of through state-guaranteed mechanisms.
At the same time, price caps will also be established. If the price lies above these agreed price caps, the proceeds are skimmed. Our short study concludes that this instrument should be implemented imminently.
The division of the uniform electricity price area results in theoretical cost advantages for the energy system, which, however, are counteracted by macroeconomic disadvantages in the practical implementation. In order to decide in favour of this or another solution political and economic aspects also need to be examined.
The imminent implementation of the grid expansion is, however, a fundamental condition for the preservation of the universal electricity price area. Already today there are cost differences relevant to network charges, which tend to be higher in the regions with a high share of electricity generated with renewables. A reform of network charges could possibly achieve much bigger incentives for system efficiency than a division of the universal electricity price area.
Our short study examines political instruments that could drive the energy market transformation forward. For this purpose, specific aspects of these instruments were collected and quantitatively assessed. The electricity price forecasts for summer 2023, compiled on behalf of the vbw, was used as a basis. The current expansion goals of the Renewable Energy Act were taken into consideration in the modelling of energy prices.
To the study (PDF, in German)
More information on the vbw website
Project team: Sven Kreidelmeyer
Last update: 27.02.2024
Senior Project Manager
What is the status of the energy transition in Germany? Since 2012, Prognos has been monitoring the energy transition in Bavaria and Germany on behalf of the vbw.
Energy prices remain high, and the expansion of renewable energies continues to fall short of targets: this is shown by our 14th Energy Transition Monitoring report, which we compiled on behalf of the vbw.
On behalf of the BMWE, we evaluate the impact of the BEG in the funding period 2021 – 2025 together with ifeu, ITG, and FIW.
Prognos and its partners support the preparation of the German government's 2025 to 2027 greenhouse gas projection reports.
On behalf of the Swiss Federal Office of Energy (SFOE), we conduct an annual analysis of the development of energy consumption in Switzerland.
The analysis for the Federal Office of Energy shows that final energy consumption has fallen significantly since 2000, mainly thanks to savings in space and process heating. At the same time, demand has risen in areas such as electrical appliances and building services. Consumption has not changed significantly since 2020.
How far have systems for storing and extracting CO2 developed in Europe? Our study for the German Environment Agency evaluated planned and ongoing CO2 capture projects in Europe, focusing on BECCUS and DACCUS projects.
Methane emissions from landfills are an often underestimated climate challenge. On commission by Kanadevia Inova, we investigated how these emissions develop over time and what levels they reach.
On behalf of the Energy Agency for Electrical Appliances (eae), Prognos annually examines the development in the efficiency of electrical appliances and their influence on energy consumption in Switzerland.
Prognos has been providing communications support for the network expansion of distribution network operator Schleswig-Holstein Netz since 2006.
We combine economic research and strategy consulting for sustainable decisions in politics, business and society. Our robust data, precise analyses and scientifically based findings enable fact-based progress – financially independent, politically neutral.
